Inheritance Dispute Between Generations When the Last Will Leads to Family Conflict
When it comes to inheritance, very different values often collide within families – especially between generations.
What parents or grandparents consider fair and "always done this way" is increasingly questioned by children or grandchildren. The older generation thinks in terms of duty, tradition, and family order. The younger ones, by contrast, seek equality, transparency, and participation. These value conflicts are understandable but carry significant potential for dispute: where silence once prevailed, there is now discussion – sometimes to the point of complete breakdown.
Goals of Inheritance Mediation
- Take the parties’ sense of fairness seriously
- Address emotional conflicts (e.g., jealousy, hurt feelings)
- Promote understanding between generations
- Find practical, fair solutions for asset distribution
- Preserve long-term family relationships
Typical conflicts where inheritance mediation can help:
Unequal distribution of inheritance
Favoring individual heirs: For example, when a parent clearly favors one child (e.g., by gifting a house or a larger share of money).
Compulsory share claims: If legal heirs are disinherited, they are often entitled to a compulsory share, which can lead to legal disputes.
Unclear or missing wills
No last will: If the deceased dies intestate (without a will), the distribution is governed by law — often not in line with family wishes.
Ambiguous wording: Wills that are vague or contradictory can lead to interpretation issues and conflict.
Doubts about testamentary capacity
Relatives may question whether the testator was mentally sound when creating the will (e.g., due to dementia or mental illness).
Influence over the testator
Suspicions that someone pressured or manipulated the testator into changing the will (e.g., through psychological pressure or isolation).
Disputes over estate administration
Unclear estate values: If assets are missing, undervalued, or misappropriated.
Conflicts between co-heirs: Especially in inheritance communities, e.g., disagreements over the use, management, or sale of real estate.
Inherited – and in conflict? Discover practical solutions through mediation.
Stephanie Seilern
Wie Mediation bei Erbschaftsfragen hilft:
Erbstreitigkeiten sind oft besonders belastend, weil es nicht nur ums Geld, sondern um Gerechtigkeit, Vertrauen und familiären Zusammenhalt geht. Als Mediatorin biete ich Ihnen einen neutralen Raum, um:
-
unausgesprochene Erwartungen und Enttäuschungen offen zu benennen,
-
gerechte Lösungen zu entwickeln, die die Bedürfnisse aller Beteiligten berücksichtigen,
-
emotionale Verletzungen und alte Konflikte konstruktiv aufzuarbeiten,
-
den Familienfrieden zu sichern – auch über die Erbfrage hinaus.
Status Quo
Mediation Process
Initial Consultation
Clarifying expectations and framework conditions.
Issue Collection
All points of conflict and interests are laid out.
Clarifying Interests
Developing a shared understanding of needs and desires.
Finding Solutions
Creative development of fair and realistic options.
Agreement
Formalizing the resolution to prevent future disputes.
Other Areas
Business Succession
When the leadership transition becomes a balancing act – The senior wants to run the business “as always,” while the successor aims to modernize and digitize. There is a risk of stagnation or conflict over leadership style.
Care & Responsibility
When caring for parents becomes a real test – The older generation has clear ideas about how the family assets should be distributed. The younger generations demand equal treatment or question traditional rules.
Value Conflicts
When different life perspectives lead to conflict – While the older generation prioritizes security and stability, the younger ones seek flexibility, self-fulfillment, and work-life balance.